This is one of those recipes that’s so ridiculously indulgent and mouth-watering that it’s almost too good to believe.
I recently encountered someone who haaaates bananas with a passion. I had actually never met anyone like that before but it seems like since then I keep hearing about this banana hatred. Who knew? It’s shocking to me because bananas are so unassuming! I have to admit that I don’t much like to eat a banana straight up without a little bit of crunch somewhere. They’re so soft that I seriously feel like I’m a baby eating baby food when I eat a banana. Is that weird?
So anyways, I hope YOU like bananas! Not that you need to love them, anything doused in brown sugar and butter is bound to be fabulous.
Bananas Foster French Toast Recipe Tips
Don’t let all that I’ve written below intimidate you. This really is quite a simple recipe. I just want to always give you all the information you need to be successful in the kitchen, and to answer any questions you might have ahead of time. Plus I think it helps to really understand the details of a recipe so you can master it then really make it your own!
The bread is clearly the base of any French Toast and should not be taken lightly!!! So that means no sad white sandwich bread here. My all-time favorite French toast bread will always be Challah bread. It’s already so rich and eggy that it really enhances the kind of light and fluffy yet custardy texture inside a thick slice of French toast. If you want a sturdier chewier texture, go for country-style bread or even Texas toast. Just make sure the bread you use is tightly crumbed, meaning it won’t have large holes or thick crusts.
The Milk & Eggs
Use good quality eggs and whole milk and whisk really well, there should be no unincorporated pieces of egg yolk or egg white. You could use 2% milk but you’ll loose out on some of the flavor and richness.
Cooking the French Toast
You can use a griddle, but I actually prefer a pan because I think it allows for better frying in an even layer of butter and oil. That’s right, I said oil. We’re frying in a combination of butter and oil to get the best texture and the best flavor. The oil helps to seal and crisp the outside of the bread so the inside stays nice and custardy.
As you get ready to cook, get your bread soaking in the custard mixture as close to the pan as possible to avoid drips that will make a gross mess. Let any excess drip off before you carefully place it into the hot pan. Fry for about 2 to 3 minutes per side. I like my French Toast pretty well fried and crisp at the edges! My favorite tool for slipping and remove the French toast is a fish spatula, it’s thin enough to slide right under and doesn’t pick up and transfer a bunch of grease because it’s slotted.
Don’t use overripe bananas, as they won’t hold their shape while they’re cooked.
Typically bananas foster calls for rum but I figured since this is a breakfast recipe that might be a little much. Feel free to add some after the sugar has dissolved in the butter, if you desire. It’d certainly be appropriate for a celebratory brunch!
Keep the finished slices of French Toast warm in a 250°F oven. Keep the topping warm over the lowest heat setting on the stove. This little trick makes easy work of having everything come to the table warm and ready to eat without hassle.
Taste: The banana topping is deeply sweet with caramel flavors while the french toast itself is caramelized, rich, with a lovely hint of cinnamon. When it all comes together it’s DIVINE.
Texture: The French toast is caramelized at the edges, fluffy inside and the bananas are floating in a thick sauce.
Ease: The French toast only fries on the stove-top for a few minutes before finishing off in the oven, leaving you time and space to make the banana topping.
Appearance: Absolutely, positively mouthwatering.
Pros: Perfect for a birthday breakfast, a special brunch, or just when you feel like indulging.
Would I make this again? Yes.
How to make Bananas Foster French Toast
Yield: Serves 2-3
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook: 15 minutes
2 large eggs
1/2 cup whole milk
1 teaspoon vanilla
1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
1/4 teaspoon allspice
Challah bread, cut into 6 1/2-inch slices
Unsalted butter, for frying
Vegetable oil, for frying
Bananas Foster Topping:
4 tablespoons (57 grams) unsalted butter
1/4 cup (50 grams) light brown sugar
2 firm bananas, sliced
Make the French Toast:
Preheat oven to 250°F.
In a large shallow bowl or dish whisk together eggs, milk, salt, cinnamon, and allspice. Soak as many slices in the egg mixture as possible for 5 minutes, turning once.
Heat 1 tablespoon of the butter and 1 tablespoon of the oil in a very large saute pan or griddle over medium heat. Add the soaked bread and cook for 2 to 3 minutes per side, until well browned. Add more butter and oil to the pan as needed. Once all the bread is cooked, place it on a baking tray in the warm oven.
Make the Topping:
In a small skillet, melt the butter. Add the brown sugar and stir until dissolved into butter. Add banana slices to pan, stirring so they are covered in caramel sauce. Sprinkle a pinch of cinnamon. Bananas are done when they are warmed through. Pour bananas foster mixture over French Toast.
© Handle the Heat - handletheheat.com